Star Power: 'We Live in Time' Revives the Classic Romance with Garfield and Pugh

The Hollywood landscape has sparked a decade-long debate: Where are the movie stars of the past? The solution is in the changing nature of stardom, as IP and franchises take up the box office. However, John Crowley's We Live in Time, starring Andrew Garfield and Florence Pugh, deviates from this tendency with a romantic dramedy that focuses on the strength of its leads, reminiscent of vintage Hollywood films that built star power.

Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield in 'We Live in Time.'

A24

We Live in Time follows the love story of Almut (Florence Pugh), a fiery chef, and Tobias (Andrew Garfield), a newly divorced businessman, as they navigate the ups and downs of their relationship. The film's non-linear storytelling and thematic purpose distinguish it from typical romance dramas, making it a welcome addition to the genre.

The film's technical prowess is notable, with cinematographer Stuart Bentley combining the warmth of remembrance with the brutal realities of today. Justine Wright's editing elegantly shifts between happy and melancholy tones, keeping the audience engaged. The real draw, however, is the evident connection between Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield.

Director John Crowley has a habit of showcasing emerging talent, and We Live in Time is no exception. Pugh and Garfield provide crisp, genuine performances that add depth to their characters. Their bodies and personas serve as the foundation for Almut and Tobias' courtship, making it all the more credible.

While We Live in Time attempts to challenge standard romantic drama conventions, it eventually returns to familiar territory. The shift in gender stereotypes is a good departure, but the predictable ending and lack of conflict resolution feel like squandered possibilities. Despite this, the film's distinct storytelling approach and genuine performances make it a charming, yet flawed, addition to the genre.

We Live in Time demonstrates John Crowley's obsession with non-linear narrative and the capacity of time to recontextualize tale structure. While not a home run, the film puts Crowley on the right track by highlighting his own authorship. With additional improvement, this method could result in something truly spectacular.

We Live in Time may not be able to bring back the period of movie stars on its own, but it is a step in the right direction. Films like these, which focus on actor-driven storytelling, can help foster celebrity while also satisfying audiences who crave romance and emotional depth. With its genuineness and sweetness, We Live in Time is a refreshing change from the usual blockbuster fare.

"We Live in Time" premiered at the 2024 Toronto International Film Festival. A24 will release it in theaters on Friday, October 11.